| 1235. |
—Elyas—Patron, Archbishop of York. |
| 1288. |
—Adam de Radeford—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1297. |
—Thomas Torcard — Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1324. |
—Brother Richard of Stapleford—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. Brother Will of Lenton—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1369. |
—Brother Edmund of St. Andrew—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1382. |
—Brother John of Warsop—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1398. |
—Brother Robert Bawtre—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1411. |
—Brother Robert of Chesterfield—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. Brother John of Sutton—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1433. |
—Brother Thomas Crofton—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1459. |
—Brother John Kirketon—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1478. |
—Brother John Walkeryngham—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1511. |
—Brother John Cowper—Patrons, Prior and Brothers of Newstead. |
| 1532. |
—Richard Robthorne, Presbyter. |
| 1545. |
—Will Baxter, Presbyter. |
| 1550. |
—Rad Smith, Clerk—Patron, King Edward VI. |
| 1553. |
—Egidius Darbishier—Patron, Queen Mary. |
| 1572. |
—Edw. Holte, Clerk — Patron, Queen Elizabeth Robert Grace, Clerk. |
| 1584. |
—John Thorpe, Clerk—Patron, Georgy Chaworth, High Sheriff of Notts. |
| 1617. |
—Henry Barlow, Clerk, M.A.—Patron, John Byron. |
| 1626. |
—Matthew Moore, Clerk — Patron, John Byron. |
| 1634. |
—Adam Hunte, Clerk, M.A.—Patron, John Byron. |
| 1647-8. |
—John Cantrell, Minister and Schoolmaster. |
| 1659. |
—Hy. Hatton, Clerke, a dissenting minister. |
| 1665. |
1682.—Will Seddons, Curate. |
| 1725. |
—Andrew Matthews. |
| 1730. |
—C. Franke. |
| 1741. |
—Thomas Carter. |
| 1758. |
—Thomas Nixon. |
| 1787. |
—Charles Nixon—Patron, Duke of Devonshire. |
| 1837. |
—John Valentine Austin—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
| 1848. |
—Curtis Jackson, M.A.—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
| 1862. |
—George Otter, M.A.—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
| 1879. |
—John Edward Phillips, M.A.—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
| 1904. |
—Edward Roberts, M.A.—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
| 1907. |
—Thomas Gerrard Barber, M.A.—Patron, Duke of Portland. |
